COMPLICATIONS: SPASTICITY: PHARMACOLOGICAL
TREATMENT
Pharmacological Treatment
- There is insufficient evidence to assist clinicians in a rational approach to antispastic treatment for SCI. Further research is urgently needed to improve the scientific basis of patient care (Taricco, et al 2005). Spasticity-related interventions need to be aimed at what matters most to the patient. It is critical for clinicians to understand patients' experiences to make accurate assessments, effectively evaluate treatment interventions, and select appropiate management strategies. When providers reconfigure patients' descriptions to fit neatly with a biomedical understanding of spasticity without carefully assessing the descriptions in terms of what matters most to patients, a potential risk for misappropriating interventions may arise (Mahoney, et al 2007).
- Baclofen (Lioresal), an analog of GABA (gamma-aminobutyric
acid), is probably the drug of choice in spinal forms of spasticity.
It inhibits both monosynaptic and polysynaptic reflexes by
inhibiting calcium influx into presynaptic terminals, which
suppresses the release of neurotransmitters. Baclofen is effective
in reducing flexor spasms, increasing range of motion, and
decreasing spastic hypertonia. There is a low incidence of
side effects, which may include hallucinations, confusion,
sedation, hypotonia, and ataxia. Chronic baclofen therapy
may diminish cough reflex sensitivity (Dicpinigaitis,
et al 2000). It is equivalent to diazepam in efficacy,
but has a less sedative effect and is safe and effective in
long-term use. Acute withdrawal can induce the development
of neurological symptoms, including seizure disorder, psychosis,
hallucinations, and visual disturbances (Rivas,
et al 1993).
-
Baclofen (Intrathecal) can treat spastic hypertonia in patients,
who are refractory to or cannot tolerate oral baclofen, by surgically placing
the drug near the spinal cord structures of desired action without the CNS
side effects of increased oral intake. A pump may be planted subcutaneously
in the abdomen wall, a catheter may be surgically placed into the subarachnoid
space, and the pump filled monthly by a transcutaneous injection. In addition
to treating spasticity, intrathecal baclofen increases bladder capacity and
decreases external sphincter spasticity, but does not result in normal voiding
patterns. Since intrathecal administration of baclofen achieves higher
concentrations in the spinal cord with smaller doses than oral baclofen,
the adverse CNS effects of oral baclofen at higher doses are significantly
reduced. Overdoses, however, may cause reversible coma. Abrupt withdrawal
of intrathecal baclofen can cause hallucinations, confusion, manic-psychotic
episodes, seizures, autonomic dysreflexia, hyperthermia, and rebound severe
spasticity which can be treated with oral baclofen or dantrolene
(Khorasani, 1995). Tolerance to intrathecal
baclofen has been reported (Lewis & Mueller,
1993). Clonidine can be added to the baclofen pump and both drugs
administered intrathecally if baclofen alone is ineffective or there is
increasing tolerance to baclofen (Middleton, et
al 1996). Intrathecal morphine can also reduce spasticity and pain
in SCI without the development of tolerance to or loss of beneficial effects
in long-term follow-up.
-
Diazepam (Valium) is a successful treatment for spastic hypertonia
in SCI. It facilitates postsynaptic effects of GABA, which result in an increase
in presynaptic inhibition. Diazepam is generally safe and well tolerated,
except for its sedative effect, which makes it unsuitable for patients with
brain injury. Its sedative effects can involve attention, memory, intellectual
impairment, and reduced motor coordination. Other side effects include
psychological addiction and synergistic depression when administered with
alcohol. Weight gain has been reported in SCI patients while taking diazepam
(Frisbie & Aguilera, 1995).
-
Dantrolene sodium (Dantrium) is preferred for cerebral forms of
spasticity, but may be a useful adjunct in spinal forms of spasticity in
that it is less likely to cause lethargy or cognitive disturbances than baclofen
or diazepam. It intervenes in spastic hypertonia at a muscular (rather than
a segmental reflex level), by reducing muscle action potential-induced release
of calcium into the sarcoplasmic reticulum, which decreases the force produced
by excitation-contraction coupling. It reduces the activity of phasic more
than tonic stretch reflexes, affects fast more than slow muscle fibers, and
has little effect on smooth muscle. Its most pronounced effect may be a reduction
in clonus and muscle spasms resulting from innocuous stimuli. Side effects
include mild to moderate lethargy, malaise, nausea, vomiting, dizziness,
diarrhea, and hepatotoxicity. Liver function tests are therefore monitored
periodically.
-
Tizanidine is equivalent to baclofen as an antispasmotic agent in
both cerebral and spinal forms of spasticity, but may be better tolerated,
and is as efficacious as and better tolerated than diazepam in patients with
chronic hemiplegia. An imidazoline derivative, tizanidine has an agonistic
action at some adrenergic receptor sites, prevents the release of excitatory
amino acids from the presynaptic terminals of spinal interneurons, and may
facilitate the action of glycine, an inhibitory neurotransmitter. It enhances
vibratory inhibition of the H-reflex, reduces abnormal cocontraction, and
increases the torque of spastic muscle. Like baclofen, it is more effective
in extensor than flexor musculature. Common side effects include mild
hypotension, sleepiness, weakness, and dry mouth. No significant alterations
in muscle strength or vital signs have been reported
(Nance, et al 1994).
- Clonidine has been used with fair success in SCI
patients. Now available in an adhesive patch for weeklong
transdermal delivery, it may cause syncope, hypotension, nausea,
and vomiting, but not usually abuse. Other possible side effects
include constipation and bradycardia (Rosenblum,
1993). Intrathecal clonidine may be a useful conservative
treatment of both severe bladder hyperreflexia and spinal
spasticity, with short-term effects evaluated through bolus
injection in subcutaneous port before definitive pump implantation
(Chartier-Kastler, et al 2000).
Clonidine can also be added to the baclofen pump and both
drugs administered intrathecally in patients where baclofen
alone is ineffective or there is an increasing tolerance to
baclofen (Middleton, et al 1996). Clonidine can be a powerful anti-spasmodic drug in addition to improving locomotion in a limited number of SCI subjects (Barbeau & Norman, 2003).
-
Other agents:
-
Chlorpromazine may have important modulatory effects on spastic hypertonia
due largely to its effects on the brain stem reticular formation. Combination
with phenytoin may be more efficacious, than when used alone, and may permit
the dose of chlorpromazine to be lowered, decreasing its sedative effect.
- Cyproheptadine, a 5-HT2 antagonist, has been
demonstrated to be an antispasmotic agent (Nance,
1994). Drug absorption (and therefore dosing)
vaires among SCI patients withlesions above and below
the sympathetic outflow (T6) (Segal,
et al 2000).
- Fampridine-SR (sustained release 4-aminopyridine)
significantly reduced spasticity in SCI patients with
incomplete injuries with minimal side effects, such as
transient lightheadedness and nausea (Potter,
et al 1998). 4-Aminopyridine may also be
useful to restore useful motor function (Segal
& Brunnemann, 1998), improve impaired central
motor conduction of some patients with incomplete SCI
(Wolfe, et al 2001),
enhance pulmonary function (Segal,
et al 1999), and improve glucose tolerance (Segal, et al 2007). Drug absorption (and therefore dosing)
varies among SCI patients with lesions above and below
the sympathetic outflow (T6) (Segal,
et al 2000). Intrathecal administration at a rate
of 5 microg/h offers the potential to focus therapeutic
effects to the lesion while minimizing systemic side effects
(Halter, et al 2000). Fampridine-SR can improve Subject Global Impression (SGI) in motor-incomplete SCI and show potential benefit on spasticity. It is well tolerated, but adverse effects include hypertonia, generalized spasm, insomnia, dizziness, pain, constipation and headache (Cardenas, et al 2007).
-
Gabapentin may be useful in the management of spasticity associated
with SCI (Gruenthal, et al 1997), and
specifically for some features of spasticity
(Priebe, et al 1997).
-
Ketazolan is as effective as and less sedating than diazepam in spinal
forms of spasticity, may have a similar pharmacologic action, and can be
administered in a single daily dose. It is not available in the U.S.
-
Progabide and Tetrahydroisoxazolopyridin, GABA agonists, are
possible antispasticity drugs that reduce spastic hypertonia, tendon reflexes,
and flexor spasms. Progabide does not significantly improve voluntary strength
and, in higher doses, may cause fever, weakness, and elevated liver enzymes.
-
Threonine has a modest but definite antispastic effect, in patients
with spinal spasticity, with minimal side effects
(Lee & Patterson, 1993).
-
Valproic acid has been demonstrated to greatly diminish the frequency
of myoclonic jerks with minimal side effects in a patient who failed or was
intolerant to baclofen, dantrolene, and diazepam
(Andary, et al 1997).
|
The Complications site of the PoinTIS
Spinal Cord Medicine site of the SCI Manual for Providers is based on information
in Spinal Cord Injury; Medical Management and Rehabilitation, G.M. Yarkony,
ed., Gaithersburg, MD, Aspen Publishers, 1994, except for information where
other papers are cited and the Consortium for Spinal Cord Medicine at the
PVA(Paralyzed Veterans of America) site for Autonomic dysreflexia and
Thromboembolism.
|